Cozy Up with These Fall Treats in Overland Park
It's officially the second most magical time of the year!
This fall, make your way to these local Overland Park bakeries and dessert shops for sweet treats packed with flavors like pumpkin, caramel, apple, cheesecake and more.
No matter what you're craving, these local flavors are sure to satisfy your autumn sweet tooth.
The Upper Crust
The Upper Crust is a locally owned pie shop in Downtown Overland Park.
They offer an impressive selection, including whole 9-inch pies and their adorable 5-inch "cutie pies" that are perfect for those who want to indulge without going overboard.
But the menu doesn't end with pies... There are cookies, macarons, quiches, and even home goods that are perfect for holiday gifting.
If you're looking to order a pie for Thanksgiving, make sure to check out their FAQ and get your order in before November 15, 2026!
Popculture
When you think of desserts, popcorn may not be the first thing that comes to your mind. But at Popculture, popcorn is transformed into a gourmet, mouthwatering dessert.
For the fall season, they have filled their sampling wall with fun and unique autumn flavors like Pumpkin Cheesecake, Pumpkin Spice and Chiefs-inspired flavors like Tailgate. This sweet and savory combo includes BBQ (flavoring from Gates), White Cheddar, Caramel and Cinnamon.
This is such a fun spot for flavor sampling and picking up the perfect unique gifts for the holidays or anytime snacking.
The Golden Scoop
The Golden Scoop is a non-profit ice cream shop. They employ and empower Super Scoopers, who are very talented individuals who happen to live with a disability.
Don’t miss their seasonal coffee drinks like the Pumpkin Cheesecake or Caramel Apple Latte, and handmade ice creams with flavors like Pumpkin Pie and Sea Salt Caramel Crunch.
By shopping at The Golden Scoop, you're supporting meaningful employment for people with unique abilities and getting a sweet treat. We call that a win-win!
Flying Cow Gelato
Treat yourself to Italian gelato, luxury chocolates and candies at The Flying Cow Gelato Shop in Downtown Overland Park.
This fall, try a scoop of Pumpkin Pie Gelato topped with graham cracker crumbles and fresh whipped cream.
Browse the candy counter for Chocolate Pumpkins, Fall Nonpareils, Halloween Oreos, Skeleton Bark and Caramel Apples.
Slow Rise
Spend a fall weekend grabbing a delicious sourdough doughnut from Slow Rise.
Their weekly drops feature a changing lineup of flavors like Spiced Apple, Pumpkin Cheesecake, and Dirty Chai.
Make sure to check their Instagram or Facebook to see what’s on the menu before you visit.
The shop is only open Thursday, Friday and Saturday mornings. Plan to arrive early, as the lines can get long!
Mo Pie
Bring a Mo Pie to your 2026 Thanksgiving table!
Founder Curt spent over two decades as vice president of Tippin’s before starting his own pie company, putting quality ingredients at the center of every recipe.
Try one of their fall flavors like Pumpkin Cream Cheese, Chocolate Bourbon Pecan or Caramel Apple!
Find them at McGregor’s Butcher Shop and the Overland Park Farmers Market.
With so many delicious options, it's clear that Overland Park is the place to be for fall-inspired treats this season.
So, gather your friends, support these local businesses, and treat yourself to the best autumn flavors Overland Park has to offer.
Related Stories
Restaurants Open on Thanksgiving in Overland Park, Kansas
Make Thanksgiving 2026 the best one yet by letting someone else do the cooking!
Where to See Fall Foliage in Overland Park: 8 Beautiful Spots for Autumn Colors
Fall is my favorite season to explore Overland Park. There are always beautiful parks, trails, and drives in Overland Park, but they really show off in the fall, changing into an array of oranges, yellows…
Fall in Love with These Overland Park Coffee Shops
As the cool autumn air arrives and the leaves begin to change, coffee shops in Overland Park, Kansas deliver delicious seasonal drink menus.
Related Content:
